By: S. Davis
Colin Kaepernick began his silent protest, sitting, on the bench for three games during preseason action before there was any uproar. Once noticed he respectfully declined interviews for weeks. His demonstration flew under the radar as he put himself on the bench instead of kneeling. When he finally gave an interview for his actions he stated that he was going to continue “to stand with the people who are being oppressed. When there’s significant change and the flag represents what it’s supposed to represent, and this country is representing people the way it’s supposed to, I’ll stand.” It was a response to combat racial injustice and systematic oppression and to lend his voice to those “dying in vain.” He was protesting the failure of the country to be a place for all, to be a place protective of all its citizens.
Kaepernick expressed his “great respect for the men and women that have fought for this country.” He’s aware that our military “fights for freedom, they fight for the people, and for liberty and justice for everyone.” He also said that “people are dying in vain” because “freedom, justice and liberty” isn’t being afforded to “everybody.”
To ensure that he wasn’t being disrespectful to the military he met with Green Beret Nate Boyer who advised him to kneel for the last preseason game in deference to the flag. Boyer stated, “Soldiers take a knee in front of a fallen brother’s grave, you know, to show respect. When we’re on a patrol and we go into a security halt, we take a knee, and we pull security.” He talked to a veteran so it wouldn’t be twisted and viewed as unpatriotic.
At that point, most of America lost their minds and ignored the reasons why he decided on his course of action. Entirely.
It was never about Kaepernick craving attention. If that was the case he would’ve brought attention to himself before anyone noticed him on the sidelines. He avoided that.
As for the anthem – written by F. Scott Key; a lawyer, poet and staunch anti-abolitionist – it’s trash and African-Americans don’t have to stand for it. It wasn’t written for them or any minority to be frank. Lastly, the great writer of the Star-Spangled Banner owned slaves. It’s abhorrent that it’s the song to represent ALL Americans. No.
Is that patriotic?
As for Kaepernick the player, yes, he experienced a notable decline after his ascent. That can’t be denied. However he also spent his last few seasons as a starter recovering from injury, mind you. He dealt with a changing franchise around him, a coaching purge and a below average skill position group, notably at receiver; I don’t think any of them are still in the NFL. His receivers also led the league in total drops. With that he started 11 games and lost 10 if I recall. Bad. The entire team was responsible for that record; not solely one player. He threw 16 touchdowns to four interceptions with a 59% completion percentage. Since when is a 4:1 touchdown to interception ratio indicative of a washed up quarterback? He’s credentialed to be an NFL starter today.
It’s not unpatriotic to protest an oppressive government that won’t look in the mirror. When that anthem plays there are a lot of people on their phones, selling and buying concessions, laughing and joking, etc. Playing the national anthem before sporting events is an American tradition. I’ve attended soccer matches across the world and there was one time where a national anthem was performed. It was done to honor the recent death of a police officer; other countries don’t do it. Also the NFL started this TRADITION of having players on the field for it all the way back in…2009. History.
Had he been named Tom Brady and took a knee, white people wouldn’t have an issue at all. They’d scream, “Yeah, you know Brady’s right about America. We need to make things equal. GO PATS!”
It’s Kaepernick’s right or anyone’s right to protest. Those are the liberties that soldiers fight for; not a piece of cloth. (If the NFL cared so much about patriotism they wouldn’t have collected six figures per team, at least the teams that were reported, for “paid patriotism.” Secondly, if America cared so much about its veterans then none of them would be homeless and arriving home broken and left on their own.)
Now his right to protest doesn’t protect him from the backlash but there wouldn’t be one if people stopped screaming to listen. There are so few people who listen to one another anymore. Those that are angry and loud are just a sample size of the larger problem.
America was founded on a protest. He’s protesting racism. It still exists. Minorities aren’t making it up. We protested England because they were oppressive and wanted to hold us under rule. Was it un-British of us to break away from the crown?
Was does it stand for anymore? Depending on where or who you are, and your skin color – because America always reminds you of it – your response will vary. It’s obvious that it’s no longer a land for everyone. It’s been made clear that a select few are deemed fit to attempt to even participate in the American Dream.
Protest? I’ve been ruminating on the label affixed to the NFL players in regards to their demonstrations during the national anthem; again, which was penned by a slave owner and wasn’t representative of a multicultural America. It isn’t a protest.
Complaints coming in state that the national anthem is “not the time” to protest; however the players have chosen to be silent in their “protest.” Choosing silence in an attempt to express deference to the flag and the national anthem; Kaepernick took a knee to be respectful. Protests are meant to disrupt and make everyone uncomfortable. To protest is to express an objection to what someone has said or done. It is to be a statement or action expressing disapproval of or objection to something.
Now we’re splitting hairs at this point but I don’t want to label the actions of the NFL players as a protest by the standard definition. It’s a call to attention. To shed light on centuries of oppression – and the vicious ripples it creates – that minorities are too familiar with while the whites in America wish to avoid the conversation or dismiss it as “nonexistent” or something that happened “years ago.”
Don’t protest! Protest at a different time! Make sure it’s a silent protest if you do! Let’s focus on that last one. So a silent protest is what America wants? OK! America’s so progressive and we’ll accept a silent protest because it’s neat and tidy for the country, correct?
I know this is true because a lifetime of silent protests and speaking out eloquently on the plight of African-Americans and other minorities in ‘merica led to a long, healthy life – and peaceful death of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. He was afforded the time to see his children age into adulthood before he expired due to natural causes and old age.
Silent protest! America’s amenable to that.
What does the flag represent? Initially it stood for the extermination and exploitation of Native Americans. It’s a complicated symbol for African-Americans. In present day it’s waved in the face of Muslims and Mexicans and to them it says they’re not welcome on these shores. Is this representative of America?
This is a country of immigrants. When the Europeans invaded these shores guess what they were doing? Immigrating to a land that didn’t ask for them; so now we’re turning our backs on the plight of the immigrants that mean us no harm? Who want to create better lives for themselves and their families? There’s hypocrisy in that. Are all men created equal…here?
Yet someone taking a knee – on advice from a military veteran – or raising a fist is unpatriotic?
So is it acceptable that some groups in our country clutch the American flag in one hand and a Confederate flag in the other? A Nazi flag stitched together with an American flag and draped over someone’s shoulders? How about when the red-white-and-blue is waved in the hands of those wearing pointed white hoods spewing hate speech – and the purity of a white (only) nation?
Why isn’t that detestable? Why isn’t that unpatriotic? Why aren’t the majority of Americans or ALL Americans upset about that?
By: S. Davis
Funny how in the aftermath of the Michael Vick interview with Jason Whitlock people are now jumping behind a guy that was maligned for his play as a quarterback and the decisions he made on and off the field of play. So he’s the one to rally behind as it relates to Colin Kaepernick’s abilities under center? Oh the lines people draw….
Vick had to ingratiate himself to any and all who would listen. Furthermore he needed the vetting of Tony Dungy just to get the ball rolling on his NFL career when he was released from prison. His advice to Kaepernick was genuine and I feel that he was doing it for the greater good of the quarterback’s future – but you have to view it from Vick’s distinct point of view. There were steps to take; he had a list of objectives he needed to meet in order to earn his desired result: employment in the National Football League. His whole existence – as far as the NFL is concerned – is to redeem himself in the eyes of the power brokers. Even now, as a retired player, he’s still on the redemption tour when doing goodwill for his youth camps and outreach for his commitments related to charities involving animals. These are the lenses in which he’s viewing Kaepernick – and the barriers he’s facing in resuming his career.
It is not even close to being in the same universe.
Football is my favorite sport but I personally may go without my favorite way to kill time – until Kaepernick is signed or he retires. So people who have taken lives, although not through convicted murder, can line up on Sundays. You can beat your wife and assault other human beings, drive drunk and kill animals but someone who happens to be African-American QUIETLY protests and that’s the line? That’s the transgression that the league deems as too extreme?
We can’t have that in our game!
How odd is that? Why don’t white people, by and large, understand that the American experience isn’t the same for everyone? It isn’t.
Hey, white people do you remember that tiny, secret, work-exchange program called slavery. It happened. No matter how much you want to forget it. Listen this isn’t a diatribe against white America but we all view this country based on our experiences. Your worldview is built upon those experiences – and the black experience is not remotely close to those who happen to be in the majority in America.
Why the hell are white people so sensitive about the truth of this country? This ridiculous stance the league is taking against Kaepernick is proof.
Vick needed a fresh start. He was convicted of a crime and went to jail. He needed to make things right and be redeemed. There was a legitimate stigma and baggage that followed him. He had a mandate to be presentable to the 32 owners and general managers in the league.
Kaepernick carries no such baggage and, no, he doesn’t need to visit the barber. He doesn’t need to apologize. He doesn’t need to seek redemption. He didn’t do anything wrong.
On the “Dan Patrick Show” yesterday Vick was thoughtful and apologetic. “I think it was taken out of context in regards to what I was trying to convey, but I only want to help Colin Kaepernick. I’m not a general manager, I’m not the guy who makes the decisions on getting him signed, and I’m truly sorry for what I said. I think I should have used a better choice of words. Obviously we all know his afro has nothing to do with him not being signed.”
Why isn’t he signed to a contract yet? It’s the end of July. There are not 32 quarterbacks in the league fit to start. Kaepernick was a handful of plays away from having a Super Bowl ring on his hand. He had 16 touchdowns against four interceptions last season when possessions/turnovers is the most important facet of football. There’s not a single job for him?
Outside of the game, he’s an activist donating time and money to the causes that inspire him. If Tom Brady led the exact silent protest I wonder how he would be viewed, covered and dissected. I know the answer, he’d have a church erected in his honor and the country would cite him as the coming of a new deity. People already worship him as if he is one.
If whites protest an issue that draws their attention they’re viewed as passionate and true Americans whereas any protest involving African-Americans (and other minorities) get labeled as malcontents, mobs, and breeding a dangerous element. It’s shameful and the media covers things in such a way where it’s normal for them to pass those adjectives out.
This country was started on a rebellion. Americans wanted freedom of expression, clear of tyranny and rule from Great Britain. America protested. America fought. American gained its independence and in that same vein mandated that its citizens do the same. Yet a quarterback staging a quiet and personal protest against the National Anthem – which was penned by a slave owner and anti-abolitionist – is wrong for exercising his right? What he’s doing couldn’t be more American in nature.
He doesn’t need to apologize. He doesn’t need to seek redemption. He didn’t do anything wrong.
By: S. Davis
I see you America. I see exactly what you’re saying in attacking Colin Kaepernick’s right to protest (quietly) by refusing to stand for “The Star-Spangled Banner.” As an American citizen he has the right to stand (or sit) for his beliefs, regardless of whether it’s popular or not. I guess that a large number of those angered by his choice forgot how this country was founded.
Those feeling disrespected are focused on what he did instead of why he did it. Of course that’s the case because that’s what the ignorant chorus is likely to do….it’s standard operating procedure.
“He’s disrespecting the military.”
Is that true? He clearly stated in his chat with the media over the weekend that he means no disrespect to anyone in the military, past or present, and that he has veterans within his family. Veterans are voicing their opinion and it seems that most disagree but there are some that don’t have an issue with his actions.
When did joining the military drape someone in a halo and a cloak of perfection? So every single person that’s active or former military is above everyone else? The professions I hold in the highest esteem are the armed forces, teachers, social workers and firefighters but there’s not a single person on this planet that’s perfect and can’t be wrong.
People are infallible, clearly, and that extends to those in the military. Military members have received traffic tickets, screamed at their children, cheated on taxes, got into fistfights, cheated on their spouses, been incarcerated, etc. You get the point, right? They’re human just like the rest of us. I don’t agree with veterans who call his position wrong but I respect and value their opinion.
America does a great job of disrespecting its own military by not paying them enough and not caring for them post-active duty. How many homeless veterans do you encounter regularly? How many of these soldiers are returning, broken, to a country that does little for all their sacrifice? It seems the best ones love this country more than it loves them. I could be wrong though. The country conveniently ignores the plight of service members once they return to our shores. Why isn’t that un-American?
“He’s disrespecting those that died for our flag.”
There’s not a single person that died for the fabric that makes our flag – which is increasingly manufactured OUTSIDE of America, by the way. They sacrificed themselves for what the symbol represents.
They died so he could protest; so he could speak against wrongs in this country. It’s that simple. He’s honoring what they took up arms for.
What exactly does the flag represent?
It’s a conflicting sight for African-Americans and other minorities. We don’t know how to feel about the flag, the national anthem or the Pledge of Allegiance. The three of them were created by whites during a time when slavery was big business, the main business. The national anthem wasn’t written with African-Americans in mind. The Pledge of Allegiance wasn’t created to include minorities. The flag is a symbol…of something.
There isn’t a single thing about Kaepernick’s position that’s incorrect. He’s right on all accounts. Systemic racism, injustice for minorities… “Liberty and justice for all?” Where is he off-base? America is this proposed utopia…for a select few. Ignorant whites are really uncomfortable about that and they need to wake up and realize there are two versions of America. Informed people – of all colors – understand and don’t run from it. African-Americans, specifically, see the contradictions in what this country actually is and what it claims to be.
Why doesn’t America care about racism?
Why does America continue to oppress non-whites?
I hear the screams about the rich, black, quarterback and how “he needs to leave the country.” I’ve read the outrage about him making “millions” and “cashing his American checks” because I guess being rich overrides his skin tone. Where is the outrage about how divided this country still is? There is none except for those suffering: Americans of color.
Why does the Civil Rights Act even exist? Why did it have to be written into law? Whites didn’t have to fight for the right to vote, ever. Why did minorities? This country was so vehemently against equal rights that millions of black people had to die just so we could gain the same equality that whites are gifted at the time of birth. There isn’t a white Civil Rights Act, it isn’t needed.
Why does the hypocrisy of this country go unnoticed?
I remember paying attention in history class when the topic of World War II was on the syllabus. (Personally, it’s a moment in time that fascinates me. I’m completely enthralled by it. It has so many layers.) So America finally entered the war, reluctantly, to stop an evil dictator who was killing a select group of people due to his own twisted bigotry and ideal of racial superiority. Thousands of innocent Jewish people where being exterminated for…being Jewish. That’s it.
We were steadfast in our resolve to make a statement and end the racism, oppression and murder that Adolf Hitler was dolling out across Europe. Our troops played their part in ending the war, returned home and America continued to oppress and limit the rights of African-AMERICANS. That was America, then. We fought for the freedom of Europeans but resisted the same freedom for fellow Americans…whose only crime was darker skin.
Is that disrespectful? Is that a symbol of a united America?
America is proficient at this. We fought for our rights when we felt we were under an oppressive regime. We rebelled against Great Britain because they blocked our freedom, our rights to exist, our religious freedoms, our right to form a nation, etc. We revolted against subjugation – and then subjugated an entire race.
I remember asking my grade school teachers about this in comparison to what happened during WWII – and I recall blank stares and a great deal of stammering.
Can we still ignore that? Are you still cool with that white America?
This is directed at white people who keep their heads in the sand or say he’s “un-American.” What does being American truly mean? The answer will differ depending on the person being asked – and their skin tone…and that’s bullshit. It was bullshit during the formation of this country, during the Civil War, Reformation, the Civil Rights Era and it’s bullshit in 2016.
That Kaepernick is an athlete doesn’t matter much. I like that it’s a huge story because he’s an athlete and this country worships sport and celebrity. There’s no way to avoid it but it’s ok, America. The news cycle will churn swiftly to sweep this under the rug. We all know that.
People don’t like that he protested in the manner in which he did, ok. What type of protest would’ve been acceptable? What would’ve made his actions easier to digest? I respect that he stood out, alone, instead of with the backing of other athletes.
Liberty and justice for all? Not if you have a natural tan.
This country loves symbols and maybe that’s why it has such a hard time removing the Confederate flag. Why does that flag still exist? The only place that piece of cloth should hang is in a few museums and that’s it. However its defenders claim it’s a sign of “southern pride and values.” Who do these values belong to exactly? It’s racist. It’s disgusting. It’s hurtful.
People lauded the politicians of South Carolina for taking it down but it should have never been raised in the first place. Does this country want to keep racism alive? Does America want to really end racism? Or does it just need to hold on to these little trinkets to remember that they held that power in an overt way?
Stop making an issue about what Kaepernick did. Please, focus on why he did it. I’ m not rich but I’m black and I’m conflicted about the flag and this country depending on what day it happens to be.
He protested the country and its government. Like it or not it’s American. If anything else lives up to the definition it’s his actions. It’s akin to the time during the birth of this nation when we spoke out collectively and were stamped as “un-British.”
Focus on why he protested. That’s where all the attention should be pointed. The reasons of his protest are the only things that matter here.
By: S. Davis
When the response to anything related to Black Lives Matter is “All Lives Matter,” well, it directly comes across as short-sighted, disrespectful and heavy-handed in nature. It carries a subtext of “shut up and go away.” When activists are chanting it, having it applied to shirts and banners and making it newsworthy, it’s not because they believe that black lives mean more than any others on this planet or more specifically, America. It’s just to simply highlight that for most of this country’s history ONLY white lives have been deemed relevant, important and worthy of defending.
Black lives don’t matter as much as white ones in this country. There’s no disputing that. This country was built on the back of slaves, Africans. They were viewed as property so of course they held the same level of relevance as a cup, dish or scissors but they were far more lucrative to their owners based on the amount of work – and commerce they were able to generate. Remember those good ole Southern boys wanted to ensure “southern values” and their “way of living” by dying in combat over their position to have slavery exist in perpetuity.
In addition to blacks being owned in this land of the free they had the glory of being counted as three-fifths of a person in the U.S. Constitution of 1787 (Article I, section 2). Over time the clause has been misinterpreted to mean that blacks were counted as three-fifths of a person or three-fifths of a complete citizen of the country – although I clearly see why anyone could make that argument. I won’t even dispute them. The clause was written to count enslaved blacks as three-fifths of their white counterparts for direct representation in Congress. Even with the correct explanation of the clause a simple question of, “Why aren’t all lives equal on a one-to-one basis?” can easily be posed. This is another instance of black lives being devalued.
Why don’t people understand this? Why are some whites afraid to admit that blacks and other minorities have been discriminated against since…forever? Why do they insist racism is “in the past” and slavery “wasn’t that bad”?
In an interview on the Brian Lehrer Show, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio said “The Black Lives Matter movement, and what it stands for, is important for this country. The very phrase ‘black lives matter’ is an absolute and direct response to a broken history in this country of structural racism in this country. It is a necessary movement.” De Blasio is a white man if things like that matter to any of you and his wife’s black as well…again, if that matters.
While I don’t agree completely with the BlackLivesMatter movement – in so much as I find their lack of response to black-on-black crime to be unsettling – I understand what drives them and what they’re doing is important.
When Black Lives Matter is heard there should be NO rebuttal at all. It isn’t needed. It’s not being expressed as a matter of dissension. It’s being said to remind those who pine for the days of slavery, segregation and ignorance that we won’t just sit idly on the sidelines and accept death. Simply put, black lives deserve an equal amount of respect as any other humans in this country – and on this planet. Yet there are those that want to fight against that…in 2016. Just take a look at the Republican nominee in the race for the White House.